Even if your day-to-day look skews more no-makeup than no-makeup-makeup, it’s always fun to amp up the glam while watching the ball drop. Still, the extra-AF, glitter-filled formulas you swing for a New Year’s Eve party beat aren’t necessarily ones you’ll reach for every day (though they certainly can pull double duty). That’s why our favorite picks for a glam night out on the town all ring in at less than $25, without compromising on pigment or staying powerful. Scroll on to discover the prettiest New Year’s Eve makeup that won’t blow your end of the year budget.